1. Home
  2. Religion & Spirituality
  3. Judaism
Ask Rabbi Simmons
Torture  
  Ask the Rabbi Pages
• Ask Rabbi Simmons Home
• 
A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P R S T U V W Y Z

  Related Resources
• Introduction to Judaism
• Jewish Holidays
• Jewish Lifecycle Events
• Jewish How To Pages

Question

A friend of mine were discussing the question of torture. Specifically, given the context of the last few months, would it be ethical to torture a person if it were known that this person had knowledge of a nuclear bomb in a large city. We don't know which city or when it will happen, but we suspect he has the knowledge. We both agreed that the ethical questions were difficult. I am writing to you if you know of any Talmudic web resources that can answer this question. I have been searching for 2 days and have not found one.

Answer

This is indeed a difficult question.

Certainly the accusations that this person has the knowledge has to be very well based; not just a conjecture. Once authorities decide that there is hard evidence that this person does have such information, it is probably a duty to apply reasonable physical pressure on this person to reveal what he knows, in order to save lives. (source: "Maimonides" Laws of Murder 2:4-5; based on Talmud Sanhedrin 46a)

The Talmud has been translated into English by "Soncino" and "Artscroll" (artscroll.com). However, the Talmud translation has not yet been posted on a website.

With blessings from Jerusalem,

Rabbi Shraga Simmons
Aish.com

More Answers from Rabbi Simmons

 

Subscribe to the Newsletter
Name
Email





Explore Judaism
About.com Special Features

Ten common misconceptions about Islam debunked. More >

Use these prayers to inspire and inform your own conversations with God. More >

  1. Home
  2. Religion & Spirituality
  3. Judaism

©2009 About.com, a part of The New York Times Company.

All rights reserved.