| Ask Rabbi Simmons | |
|
Question
Exactly why is Shatnez (clothing of wool/linen blends?) prohibited?
In answering this question, please be aware that I'm as interested in the process as I am in the answer. I'd like to learn more about how to find the answers to such questions. So where does one look? How does one know where to look? If the answer is found in the Talmud, how does one determine what the rule is from the discussion?
Answer
Shalom!
The Torah prohibits wearing clothes made out of wool and flax, as it is written, "You shall not wear combined fibers, wool and linen together." (Deuteronomy 22:11) In Hebrew, this forbidden mixture is called "Shatnez."
The Torah does not explain the reason for Shatnez, and it is categorized as a Chok - a law that cannot be explained. (As opposed to a Mishpat - which is law that can be derived from logic).
Nevertheless, different reasons have been suggested.
Rabbi Aaron Halevi of Barcelona wrote in his book "Sefer HaChinuch - The Book of Mitzvah Education" the reason why it is forbidden to mix wool and linen together is because it destroys the spiritual fabric of the universe. This can be explained as follows: Each and every thing on earth, except for man, has its own spiritual force that influences it. When some of these earthly items are mixed together, they cause their spiritual counterparts to become entangled. Once entangled, they cannot perform their tasks as originally designed, thusly destroying the spiritual fabric of the universe. However, after the explanation, the author tacked on "We still need a Mystic to explain this." (Sefer HaChinuch - The Book of Mitzvah Education #62)
Another explanation, from the Talmud suggests that the reason stems from the fact that when Kain and Abel brought offerings to G-d, one of them brought flax (the plant that linen is made from) and the other brought a sheep (where we get wool from). For some reason, this mixture ended up being lethal and Abel lost his life. (See Genesis 4:1-17 and the Midrash - Genesis Rabbah)
Whatever the reason, the laws of Shatnez are still applicable today, and one can find many Shatnez laboratories that can check to see if one's clothing contains Shatnez or not.
As for books for further research, I suggest the Artscroll Stone Chumash, which is a brilliant translation of the Five Books of Moses with a running commentary on every page culled from the Talmud, Midrash and other Torah commentators. You can get it at any Jewish bookstore, or at www.artscroll.com.
I also suggest the "Sefer HaChinuch - The Book of Mitzvah Education" (published by Feldheim) which goes through each and every mitzvah in the Torah (including Shatnez) and explains the reasons from the various sources in the Torah and the Talmud. You can get this book at a Jewish bookstore or from www.feldheim.com.
With blessings from Jerusalem,Rabbi Shraga Simmons
Aish.com
More Answers from Rabbi Simmons
|
|

