Question

Answer

Thanks for writing and this is not an unusual situation. Allow me to share several observations.

1. If you are interested in Judaism, why not start now. Perhaps the parents are also asking that question. To convert just for marriage is not only untraditional but less than meaningful. I'll tell you that of many conversions I've performed, some started out with a significant other, the relationship broke up but the conversion continued through all of its stages. It truly was a serious religious personal commitment.

2. You may be miserable without each other now, but it is also quite possible - some say probable - that when you marry and encounter the incredible number of challenges regarding each other's background, in-laws, and of course children, you'll be even more unhappy. And, the children of such marriages frequently tell me how unhappy they are without knowing who or what they are and how they are supposed to behave and believe without "offending" one parent or set of grandparents.

3. There are no answers to appease his parents of which I am aware, certainly not knowing them. But, it may be time to sit down with them and ask them, specifically what it is that bothers them and how they feel about your conversion. Keep in mind that there are still Jews today - not that I agree with them at all - who feel that conversion is impossible; Judaism is physical and racial in their minds. Check them out.

4. You should definitely consider meeting with a Rabbi in your community and with your boy friend. If the parents don't belong to a synagogue, I'd be delighted to help you find a synagogue and Rabbi.

These should start you, your boy friend and everyone thinking.